This is part of a series of post where I try to take a fresh look at a variety of topics. You can see more about the idea for the series, and links to the other topics here. This week’s topic is “Foreign missionaries”.
So this one was interesting to write, as I initially thought that I had no opinion on the subject. I mean, yeah, sure, “go ye into all the word”, right? Foreign missionaries certainly fall into that. So sure, they are good, End of thought process, end of story. But as I thought about it more, I realized I do actually have feelings on the issue.
To start, I think that one of my mom’s biggest disappointments in life is that I didn’t grow up to be a missionary in Papua New Guinea. When I was a kid, I saw a video at church about these missionaries there, and I remember thinking that that must be the highest calling in the word. I mean, these people ate worms – just so they would be able to tell other people about God. And so I decided that when I grew up, that’s what I would do (not the worms part, though). And I stuck with that idea for years.
And then. Then my dad became a “local” missionary. He worked full-time for a ministry in town, and had to raise support and all that. And I absolutely believe he was called to do it. But the money never really showed up. And there was a lot of nasty politics involved – church politics to the n-th degree, as it were. And he left the ministry, and went back to full-time work doing what he had been doing part-time to support us the whole time he was working full-time in the ministry. And that was that.
But I got to see a lot of the ugly side of ministry. The politics, the gossip, the “you kids had better act right at this church, because your dad is asking them for support” lectures, the pressure to be perfect… and when it ended, the people who shook their heads and said either “oh, he must not have really been where God wanted him” or “He just must not have had enough faith” or whatever. And trust me, it was ugly. And it’s something I still harbor some grudges over, more than 10 year later.
So, going into college, I was a little jaded towards ministry as a career. I took plenty of missions trips – “service” trips, really – to different parts of Mississippi, where I ministered by building Habitat houses and serving soup to homeless people and whatever the project of the moment was. I ministered to the people around me (with varying degrees of success) by providing a listening ear, a shoulder when needed, and food. And I chose my (original) major, thinking that it might suit me if I decided to look into full-time missions.
But the more I thought about it, the more I felt that full-time missions wasn’t really my calling. Not in the US, and not outside of it – my calling, I feel, is to work in my church, to minister to my friends, and to be a wife and mommy. And there are just a lot of things about foreign missions that I don’t agree with.
Most foreign missionaries send their kids to boarding school. Which seems so backwards to me – shouldn’t you teach your kids, your family, before you invest time in others? But instead, these kids get shipped off to school where someone else can teach them, and their parents con concentrate on the much more important task of missionarying.
Also, it seems like a lot of missionaries want to convert people not just to Christianity, but to Americanism. Or Europeanism. And these rich cultures get lost in Nike shoes and western clothes and eventually western values. People say “Look how much better they have it! Look how much the missionaries have done for them!” And while I agree that better medical care and hygiene is generally a good thing – there comes a point where the missionaries aren’t making things better, they are just making them different. You can be absolutely just as good a christian in a hut, eating worms, barefoot, and wearing a loincloth as you can in a house with real walls, eating McDonalds and wearing sneakers and jeans.
What happened to the Hudson Taylor approach to missions? Where we go an live as one of the people, adopting their culture (insomuch as it doesn’t impact our religion), and make friends with them? Then try and talk to them about God – without equating salvation to prosperity or other modern western values. I know this is still done some places, but it seems the exception when I think it should be the rule.
So, to summarize: while I in theory support missions. And I pray for the missionaries I know, overseas and here in the US. I don’t think it is always done the right way. And it’s not something I feel called to myself – there are plenty of things for me to do here, without traveling around the world, and eating worms.