This is part of a series of post where I try to take a fresh look at a variety of topics. You can see more about the idea for the series, and links to the other topics here. This week’s topic is “The rite of communion”.
So I am currently a member of a Church of Christ church, where we take communion every Sunday. Which is nice, because it happens often, and I really like traditions and rituals and liturgy and things with meaning behind them. In a past life, perhaps, I would have been Catholic.
Our communion is an open one – at a church where “joining” the church is as simple as signing the member side of the attendance card instead of the guest side, it would be hard to have it otherwise. And I like that, too. I’ve never been a fan of the idea that you had the have signed on to a specific congregation to take communion with them – I just can’t find scriptural basis for it, really, since denominations are to some extent a modern thing.
I always feel a little odd, though, when I’m at a new church for communion. I have to spend a few minutes figuring out how they do it, to make sure I’m not going to somehow mess it up. At our church, the bread is a giant cracker (matzos, really), and everyone breaks off a tiny, tiny piece. And takes it immediately. The cup is grape juice in little communion cups, which for some reason at our church we take immediately and put the empty cup back in the little whole it came from. Which freaked me out a little the first time. Back home, everyone waiting until everyone was served, and then we all ate the bread together, then served the wine and took it – all together. At the Wesley, when we took communion, it was by intinction – we dipped pieces of actual bread into a cup of grape juice. At Aldersgate, my church in Starkville, everyone knelt at the front of the church for communion. One church I went to growing up used real wine (um, yeah. That was a surprise). There are so many variations on the theme, it just takes me minute sometimes to get my bearings.
There was a disagreement at my current church a while back about how communion should be taken – should there be two separate prayers, one for the bread and one for the cup? Or would one prayer work? Should the congregation sing during communion? Or sit in (relative) silence? And people got kind of upset – I mean, communion is one of those things you just don’t mess with. But here’s the thing. It never says in the bible exactly how it should be done – or how often. “As often as you do this”… So, every time we break bread together in a group? Every time we eat?
In the early church, communion was more like a meal that everyone ate together – no little plastic communion cups, no stale crackers, a meal. Maybe we would all be better off remembering that – and remembering Christ each time we eat, together or no – than arguing over the finer details of a ritual that, while it still has great meaning, is more traditional than biblical.


